Trusting Other People's Opinions- Gee You're Such A Slob
When they're little, these girls are often so perfect, and they delight in everyone's telling them so. They're so well behaved, they're so cute, they're so helpful, and they're so precocious. Girls learn to trust people's estimates of them. "Gee, everyone's so nice to me; if they criticize me, it must be true." Even females at the top universities in the country say that other people's opinions are a good way to know their abilities.
Boys are constantly being scolded and punished. When we observed in grade school classrooms, we saw that boys got eight times more criticism than girls for their conduct. Boys are also constantly calling each other slobs and morons. The evaluations lose a lot of their power.
A male friend once called me a slob. He was over to dinner at my house and, while we were eating, I dripped some food on my blouse. "That's because you're such a slob," he said. I was shocked. It was then that I realized that no on had ever said anything like that to me. Males say it to each other all the time. It may not be a kind thing to say, even in jest, but it certainly makes them think twice before buying into other people's evaluations.
Even when women reach the pinnacle of success, other people's attitudes can get them. Frances Conley is one of the most eminent neurosurgeons in the world. In fact, she was the first woman ever given tenure in a neurosurgery at an American medical school. Yet careless comments from male colleagues-even assistants- could fill her with self-doubt. One day during surgery, a man condescendingly called her "honey." Instead of returning the compliment, she questioned herself. "Is a honey," she wondered, "especially this honey, good enough and talented enough to do this operation?"
-From Carol S Dweck's book Mindset- The New Psychology of Success
These passages struck me about how people receive critical comments. This is not something that just pertains to girls or kids. Nobody likes to be criticized, but it is impossible to avoid criticism and attempt to do great things. It comes with the territory. The key is how do you deal with being criticized.
So I wanted to do something that deals with getting the girls to think twice when they receive criticism. In their journals I am going to have them make a section for when they receive criticism (constructive or not) or just general negative comments. (Please don't just limit this journal to soccer) They will write down:
1) What was the comment?
2) Was it constructive or fluffy? (I am using fluffy instead of useless because it is hard to say "fluffy" in a serious way. "Fluffy" will make it easier to shake off a negative comment for the simple reason that when you say "Oh that was just fluffy!", you can't help but smile.)
3) If it was constructive, what message can you take out of the comment?
4) Can you improve and how can you improve?
Example 1:
1) After I made a poor pass Ronaldo glared at me and yelled that I need to make a better pass.
2) It was constructive, though not nice, because the pass was not accurate and I could have made a better pass.
3) I made a bad pass and Ronaldo expects a better pass from me because I am a good player.
4) I can improve. My toe was down when I passed the ball. I can spend 5 minutes before each training working on my passing.
Example 2:
1) During our scrimmage Taylor was on the other team and after a collision with her she said I stunk.
2) It was fluffy. She was just upset that I stole the ball.
Try it out. If you can decipher the message out of critical comments and realize which opinions have value you will become a much more confident person.